Group 10 has done an amazing job working with the brefieng we proposed (despite the time management problems we faced Scarlete and I). But in MangoNaranja we think that everyone learns much more from their feilures than from their successes, that is why in our project presentation meeting we pointed out also the areas of improvement rather than only the good characteristics of the product.
POSTER 1: The solution proposed
The first poster we present is an objective analisis of the solution that Anatolian Eye has proposed : A cane that helps elder with their daily activities.
In this poster we show the features that they have decided to include in the cane. Every feature was clearly defined, executed, and carefully thought. GREAT JOB!
Points of improvement:
As clients, we proposed some ideas that we would have liked to see in the product. The designers developed some of those ideas but not all of them. We would have liked to know the reason why you decided to develop the ideas in one design deriection and not the other one.
In the concept generation you came up with very good ideas regarding the little details of the product, but when the refinement phase you removed a lot of those good ideas (that could coexist perfectly in the product).
Another point of improvement that we noticed is that you dind’t think outside the box during the concept generation phase and mostly all of the ideas provided were canes. We didn’t had a lot of diversity when choosing the concepts we wanted you to refine.
VIDEO: Prototype and Usage of the Solution
POSTER 2: The Solution VS the Briefing
The second poster is a more critical analysis based on the briefing we provided to our designers and also in the usage of the prototype. Each of the pictures is refered to a point of the briefing, and the numbers relate each criteria with a feature showed in the first poster.
We also show a bar of wich is the percentage of the characteristics meet. Almost all of them reach high values. GREAT JOB! You can see the point of improvement that we commented on the meeting in the right colum of each criteria.
As a resume we would like to say that we enjoyed working with you and we would like to encourage you to keep working as you did.
We also hope that we can stay in contact in the future !
The final concept is based on the selection of our customers. We were asked to further refine the idea of the carousel, but with more changes than in the last refinement.
Initially, this storage cabin had a capacity for an average of 36 preserves (depending on the size of the jars or bottles to be stored). Our customers asked us to reduce the capacity by half, as the users who live alone do not have the need to prepare so much food. At the last meeting we had, we discussed the best way to reduce the capacity: by making the cabinet lower, thinner or shallower. Our customers indicated that they just wanted to make it thinner. In order to keep the weight balance evenly distributed, in addition to making it much thinner we also reduced the depth a bit.
This change in dimentions, has lead to a modification in how the bottom notches ( the ones that store the bottle racks) are orientated. Previously, the bottle racks where inserted from the front, now from the sides . This decision (with the new dimentions ) increases capacity. We also had to dismiss the idea of having a drawer separation in the middle, cause the compact dimentions make it unnecessary.
Even so, our customers were still concerned that the cabinet might be too heavy to be moved only by an old man. The wood used in the furniture is plywood, which is already quite light, so the solution applied was to replace the tiles on the sides with wallpaper, thus preserving the Turkish-inspired decoration that our customers initially liked so much.
Lastly, our customers were concerned about the height of the interior drawers, because in the case of low canning jars, the user would not be able to see what food is stored in them. They asked us if there was a way to prevent this from happening. In our case, initially we stablished the height in order to provide stability and prevents taller jars from falling over, so the dimentions are quite tight. Our solution has been to replace the small labels that were originally placed in the trim, with a white board that takes up the whole front of the drawer. In this way the user can write down the type of food that is preserved, the date of packaging and the expiration date.
In the close up look of the oppening of the cabinet, number one refers to the fact that there is a horizontal groove through which the first slat of the door is inserted. This ensures that the door, when closed, will not fall under the weight of gravity.
In this sketch you can see the new geometries and dimentions. The rest of the features remain the same as in the previous concept.
Other considerations about the design
Dimentions of the crank
Metal details aesthetic
Wallpaper inspiration
Now we provide some videos on how does the carroussel and slider drum door mechanisms work.
Drum door mechanism
* This video includes handcrafted processes that might be inspirational for the mockup building
Carroussel mechanism
The carrousel mechanism is used in some existing products like for example a paternoster elevator, a shoe storage and much more industrial supplies storage.
*As we asume that in 1 week it is not posible to create an accurate moddel of the mechanism, we also provide some other methods to make something similar and still functional. Focusing always in asuring the stability of the box storage.
For example: If you create a prototype in a reduced scale you can use the gears of a rolling tip-ex. To conect the drawers to the mechanism you can use some wires or sticks in the sides or that pass through (from side to side).
On Sunday, we planned to meet for a discussion on our refined design ideas. However, due to a misunderstanding, we decided to postpone the session to Monday.
On Monday evening, both teams came together to share our refined ideas and provided each other with valuable feedback. The discussions were insightful, and we’re excited about the direction we’re heading!
We’ve decided to finalize and upload our final designs by Friday evening, considering the following key points:
exact dimensions for all critical components, , ensuring precision in the prototyping phase.
This is one of the two refined designs that Mango Naranja we want to present to our customers. After receiving feedback from our clients, it became clear to us that their favorite features of Cristina’s designs are: not having to bend down to reach the canned goods on the lower shelf, modularity and connection of the cabins, wooden materials and decoration of mosaic inspired by Turkish culture, the flexibility of storing preserves in different types of geometry and jar size, as well as the fact that spices can be dried in the furniture itself. Also the fact that it can be moved from the terrace to the kitchen
We have tried to put all those features in a single design. This design is based on the original design of the carousel system, from which several changes and redesigns have been made.
Changes Made
A panel has been added to the base of the furniture to prevent humidity from the terraces from damaging the preserves.
The legs have been changed to 4 swivel wheels that can be braked.
The dimensions have been slightly reduced so that it takes up less space
The carousel system has been modified. Now this is on both sides so that the crank can be changed from side to side.
Points 3 and 4 allow modularity so that the user can choose if they want to buy 1 or 2 pieces of furniture, these can be arranged side by side or facing each other from the back.
The geometry of the drawers has been modified so that bottles can be stored or a divider added.
To store the bottles, simple concave-shaped bottle racks are provided; these, if not used, could be stored in the new lower panel mentioned in point 1.
A metal rack has been added to dry the spices. This could slide along the back of the furniture with rails when not in use.
Based on what features Scarlet and Cristina liked we have come up with two refined design ideas. In our Zoom call, they said that it is not a bad idea to conceptualize the designs. We worked on mainly two personas and designed them accordingly.
1. Cane for Active Seniors (REFINED DESIGN IDEA 1)
(Vizcom geneated)
Features Of The Cane
Telescopic System (Adjustable Height): Users can modify the height of the cane to meet their demands by adjusting its length. The cane’s telescoping mechanism aids in its adaptability to various users and circumstances.
Ergonomic Hand Grip: By offering a comfortable grip, the ergonomic handle lessens the strain that extended use places on the user’s hand and wrist. The general form and construction of the cane are modeled after the design of running prosthetic legs, which are renowned for their stability and effective energy transfer. This design may contribute to improved movement and balance.
Glow in the Dark: The cane’s ability to glow in the dark improves user safety by making it simple to find in dimly lit or dark areas.
Compact Storage (Gets Smaller): The cane is easy to store or move when compressed to around 60 cm. Users who might need to put the cane away while not in use might benefit from this functionality.
Pill Storage & Walking Light: For users who need to carry medication with them, the cane’s pill storage box is helpful. In order to improve sight at night or in dimly lit areas, there is also an integrated light at the bottom that illuminates the ground ahead.
Persona Card 1
Benefits For Seniors
Enhanced Mobility and Independence: Seniors can more easily traverse outside areas thanks to the cane’s steadiness on a variety of surfaces. Seniors who have more mobility may be more inclined to engage in social activities like going on walks with others, attending community events, or just hanging out with friends. The cane helps individuals continue an active social life by improving mobility and comfort. Increased Confidence in Social Contexts: With features like a built-in light, glow-in-the-dark components, and an ergonomic hand grip, the cane gives seniors a sense of security when they’re out, even in poorly lit areas. This self-assurance could encourage individuals to go out more frequently, go to parties in the evening, or maintain relationships with friends and family without fear of tripping or falling in the dark.
Convenient Health Management: Seniors who are away from home for an extended amount of time can easily obtain their prescriptions thanks to the built-in pill storage. Seniors can join friends for extended outings, day trips, or activities without worrying about forgetting essential medications thanks to this convenience, which helps reduce any fears associated with managing health issues in social settings. Possibilities for Conversation and Social Engagement: A stylish, contemporary cane like this one can also spark an intriguing discussion. New social encounters may result from friends or others asking about its distinctive traits. By defying the stereotype of conventional mobility aids, a chic and creative cane can also give elders a sense of pride.
Convenient Storage and Portability: Seniors can take the cane on car journeys, public transportation, and even trips thanks to its collapsable construction. By allowing individuals to attend social events without having to worry about heavy mobility assistance, this portability increases their social chances.
Ideas for Materials
Shaft: The shaft is the main body of the cane and must provide strength and stability without adding unnecessary weight.
Aluminum: Lightweight, corrosion-resistant, and strong. Aluminum is commonly used in mobility aids due to its balance between strength and weight.
Handle: The handle should be comfortable, and ergonomic, and provide a good grip.
Thermoplastic Elastomers (TPE): Flexible and comfortable, TPE is often used in ergonomic designs. It offers a non-slip surface and can be molded into various shapes to create a comfortable grip.
Telescopic Mechanism: The telescopic system allows for height adjustment, so the materials must be durable and able to withstand repeated use.
Anodized Aluminum or Stainless Steel: These metals are commonly used for telescoping mechanisms due to their durability and resistance to wear.
Tip(Base): The base must provide grip and stability on various surfaces to prevent slips.
Rubber or Thermoplastic Rubber (TPR): Rubber is commonly used for cane tips as it provides strong traction and absorbs shock. TPR is also durable, flexible, and provides a reliable grip on various surfaces.
Light: If the cane includes a built-in light, durable, lightweight materials are needed for this element. LED for the Light Source: LED lights are energy-efficient, long-lasting, and compact, making them well-suited for cane designs.
2. Buddy Cane: A Helping Hand for Seniors (REFINED DESIGN IDEA 2)
This design is a thoughtful innovation aimed at empowering seniors and encouraging them to remain active in their daily lives. With a versatile, foldable structure and a unique hose-holding mechanism, it serves not only as a walking aid but also as a practical tool for gardening and other outdoor activities. By making everyday tasks more manageable, this cane encourages seniors to stay engaged in their hobbies and routines, ultimately promoting independence and enhancing their quality of life. Its multifunctional design, comfortable grip, and easy portability make it a reliable companion for seniors looking to enjoy an active lifestyle, both indoors and outdoors.
Persona Card 2
Features of the Cane:
Folding Mechanism:
The cane can be easily folded into compact sections, making it convenient to store and transport.
When extended, it locks securely into place, providing stability and support for walking.
Hose Holder Mechanism:
The cane includes a unique hose holder inspired by microphone clips. This holder secures a garden hose (or other items) in place, preventing it from slipping.
The same clip mechanism also serves to fasten the cane’s sections together when folded, ensuring that the cane remains compact.
Adjustable Clips:
The clips can be adjusted along the cane to hold various items, such as hoses, small tools, or even shopping bags, enhancing the cane’s versatility.
Comfortable Grip:
The cane handle is designed for comfort with a soft, slip-resistant grip, ideal for extended use.
Benefits for Seniors:
Improved Mobility:
The folding design allows seniors to easily carry or store the cane, making it practical for on-the-go use without taking up much space.
Support and Stability:
The firm, lockable structure of the cane provides reliable support, helping seniors maintain balance and stability while walking.
Assistance with Gardening:
The hose holder mechanism is especially beneficial for seniors who enjoy gardening, as it allows them to use the cane to hold a garden hose securely, reducing the need for bending and stretching.
Multifunctionality:
Beyond gardening, the adjustable clips offer flexibility to hold other lightweight items, like small shopping bags or tools, making everyday activities more manageable.
Comfort and Safety:
The cane’s ergonomic handle provides a comfortable grip, ensuring that seniors can use the cane for long periods without discomfort. The cane’s design also prevents slipping, adding an extra layer of safety.
Ideas for Materials:
Main Body:
Aluminum Alloy: Lightweight, durable, and resistant to rust, making it ideal for both indoor and outdoor use.
Stainless Steel: A slightly heavier option that offers even more durability and long-term strength, especially for those who need extra stability.
Clips & Hose Holders:
Rubber-Coated Metal: This material ensures that the clips are both durable and provide a firm, non-slip grip on the hose or other items.
High-Quality Plastic: Lightweight and flexible, yet strong enough to secure items without damage.
Grip Handles:
Silicone: Provides a non-slip surface and is soft to the touch, offering additional comfort during use.
Mechanisms:
Folding Mechanism:
The cane utilizes hinges or internal elastic cords to collapse into a more compact form. This mechanism ensures that the cane can be stored easily, either in a bag or closet, without taking up too much space. And also easy to use when traveling by car.
When needed, the cane can be unfolded and locked securely in place for stability.
Hose Holder Mechanism (Inspired by Microphone Clips):
This adjustable clip is the centerpiece of the design. It holds a hose securely during gardening activities, preventing it from slipping or tangling.
The same clip also functions as a fastener for the cane’s folding sections, keeping the cane compact when not in use.
Adjustable Clips:
The cane includes flexible clips that can be moved along its length to hold different items, such as a garden hose, shopping bags, or small tools. This adds versatility and convenience, especially for seniors who need an extra hand while running errands.
We had our weekly meeting on Sunday which lasted for an hour. We talked about our initial design ideas and received feedback from each other. We will give each other feedback this Sunday about our two refined design ideas.
On a first inspirational phase, I came up with these two moodboards: the firs one regarding CMF (Colors-Materials-FInishes), the second one regarding mechanisms and construction ideas.
CMF:
Sources (order is from left to right and top to bottom):
As you can see, it is made for an efortless and ergonomic use. The opening of the door from top to bottom makes it unecessary to squat in order to take the objects in the bottom shelf. By making the crank spin, the carrousel starts moving and you can grab pots from the shelf you want.
It is meant to be an static furniture, that is why stands on legs rather than wheels.
The materials I was thinking for this drawer is mainly wood, specifically plywood that is light and aesthetically appealing. But the shelfs and crank will be made up of aluminium sheet metal. In order to have aluminium shelfs, it may be necesary to add anti-slip matts, like the one shown in moodboard 2. Other additional features may be: dividers for the shelfs or holders for taller bottles as shown below.
More on, adding tiles with a turkish inspirational mosaic in the side panels, will add this homey feeling. Also I do not exclude adding leds lights if necessary, maybe inside the drawer, the shelfs or by backlighting the tags.
Please take a look at the sketch to see the global view of all the datails.
Complementary images for concept 1:
Sources (order is from left to right and top to bottom):
This second concept consist on a horizontal cabinet with a metal headboard.
The cabinet opens smoothly thanks to two sliding drum doors. Inside you can find two standard shelfs, but depending on what type of conserve it is meant to be stored, you can add a cross-shaped bottle rack or a mechanical can dispenser. This structure is made up of paywood.
More on we have the metal meshes as headboard for the furniture. Its main purpose is for hanging the drying spices, but you can add on some other hangers for a bigger storage capacity (an example of those you can find it in the complementary images). The countertop willl have some tiles with a turkish inspirational mosaic in the side panels, this feature will add a homey feeling.
Also I do not exclude adding leds lights if necessary, maybe inside the drawer, the shelfs or by backlighting the tags.
Please take a look at the sketch to see the global view of all the datails.
Complementary images for concept 2:
Sources (order is from left to right and top to bottom):
This last concept is a modular hexagonal vertical cabinet.
It is meant to used by attaching various cabinets in a lineal maner or rotatory, that for the furniture stands on wheels rather than legs like the other two concepts. To make it safer and static, those are braked wheels.
The attachment will be made by a hook fastener, disposed and leveled to the trim of the counter. The user can easily prepare the mechanism to be used, or fold it so it doesn’t disturb. And in this way, although the counter is not the principal object part, it is still usefull.
The structure is completly made of paywood, except for the counter, that has some tiles with a turkish inspirational mosaic in the side panels, this detail will add a homey feeling to the furniture.
Also I do not exclude adding leds lights if necessary, maybe inside the drawer, the shelfs or by backlighting the tags.
Please take a look at the sketch to see the global view of all the datails.
Complementary images for concept 3:
Sources (order is from left to right and top to bottom):
The idea of a seated cane can be considered as a solution for elderly people who have problems walking or need to rest after walking for a short time. Thanks to its double-layered handle and its umbrella-like opening mechanism, it can be transformed into a chair without any space. When the handle part is used for sitting, it opens from the double-folded part and when the ring on the cane part is pushed down, the stick folds and the stick part consisting of three parts provides balance.
2. Storable Support
Food shopping is as important for the elderly as it is for everyone else, and carrying the heavy items they buy when they go to the market can be a negative experience for them and they may avoid it. In order to prevent this and solve this problem, a product that gives them physical support and balance and allows them to store their purchases can make their daily lives easier.
3. Four Wheels
This product aims to support the elderly in their physical activities. It provides more solid support for those who have great difficulty walking and gives them the opportunity to lean their backs and sit when they need to rest. The sitting part can be opened when used, and when not needed, it can be folded into a coffee table and they can put the items they take with them on it.
The design concept revolves around a specialized cane that integrates features to assist elderly users in gardening activities. As many older adults engage in gardening for its therapeutic benefits, this cane will provide both mobility support and gardening functionality, making it easier for them to enjoy their hobby while maintaining their independence.
Design Features:
Hose Connection Point:A durable attachment point on the cane allows for easy connection of a garden hose. This feature enables elderly users to water plants without bending or straining, ensuring they can care for their gardens comfortably.
Hose Securing and Directing Head:The cane will incorporate a mechanism to secure and direct the garden hose. This could include adjustable clamps or guides that keep the hose in place while users water their plants, preventing tangles and ensuring efficient water distribution.
Ergonomic Handle:The handle of the cane will be designed to be comfortable and easy to grip, possibly with padded or textured surfaces. This ensures that users can hold onto the cane securely while also maneuvering the hose.
Lightweight Materials:Constructed from lightweight yet sturdy materials, the cane will be easy to carry around the garden, reducing fatigue for elderly users who may have limited strength.
Storage Compartment:A small storage compartment can be integrated into the cane to hold gardening tools, gloves, or seed packets, allowing users to have everything they need at hand while they work in the garden.
2. Companion Cane: A Caring Design for Seniors and Their Pets
The design concept revolves around a multifunctional cane not only providing support for walking but also includes features that cater to pet care, promoting an active lifestyle and social interactions for both seniors and their dogs.
Design Features:
Integrated Dog Waste Bag Dispenser: The cane will feature a discreet, attachable compartment for storing dog waste bags. This convenient dispenser allows seniors to easily access bags during walks, making it hassle-free to clean up after their pets.
Collapsible Water Bowl: A foldable, lightweight water bowl will be integrated into the cane’s design. Seniors can quickly deploy the bowl to provide water for their dogs while out on walks. The bowl can be made from durable, easy-to-clean materials.
Comfort Grip for Pet Leash: Design an additional, padded grip on the handle specifically for holding a dog leash, providing extra comfort during extended walks. This could reduce strain on the hand and wrist.
3.Customizable Cane & Workshop Experience
This idea transforms the cane into more than just a mobility aid; it becomes a platform for creativity and social interaction among older adults. The cane’s design allows for personal customization, and workshops are organized to bring seniors together to decorate and personalize their canes.
Design Features:
Modular Customization:
Interchangeable Covers: Users can attach and swap covers on the cane’s body. These covers can be painted, decorated with patterns, or adorned with knitted accessories to reflect personal stories or interests.
Photo & Memory Compartment: Small, transparent compartments on the cane allow users to display family photos, handwritten notes, or small memorabilia that hold sentimental value.
Detachable, Multi-Purpose Compartments: The cane includes small, detachable compartments that serve practical purposes, such as holding keys, medications, or emergency contact cards.
Creative Workshop Ideas:
Painting & Decorating Workshops: Participants learn techniques to personalize their canes using paint, stickers, or textile elements like crochet or embroidery.
Memory Sharing Sessions:While customizing their canes, participants can share the stories or memories they’re representing, creating a sense of community and connection.
Glow-in-the-Dark Finish: The cane is equipped with a luminous coating that glows in the dark This feature improves visibility during nighttime walks, which allows the user to more easily find the object and increase safety in dimly lit areas.
Secure Gripping Surface: The handle and bottom of the cane are covered with, rubber. This ensures a firm grip, even in wet conditions, which is particularly useful for older people with less grip strength or balance.
Stability Enhancements: This minimizes the risk of slipping, particularly when walking on various surfaces such as sidewalks or wet surfaces. The base of the cane features a rubber-tipped foot with a jagged surface that provides additional stability. The bottom of the cane is inspired by the prosthetic leg runners use.
Curve for Leash for Pets: This ensures furry friends can walk with their owners. Since seniors can have a hard time both gripping the cane and leash, combining two of them in one hand makes the other free. This provides comfort in every area of life.
Oscar Pistorius of South Africa runs in the men’s 200-meter event at the Paralympic World Cup in May. Some observers have suggested Pistorius receives an unfair advantage from his carbon-fiber “blade” legs.
My sketch
2. Cane for Local Market Days
Hooks for Bags: Especially on local market days, seniors have difficulties carrying bags of fruits and vegetables. Going to local markets is one of the freedoms of seniors and they enjoy going there and socializing. This cane design aims to have hooks for bags so that seniors have one hand free which is important for balancing and communicating.
Medical Storage Compartment: Users might be able to keep medication, such as an emergency inhaler, or a tiny pillbox. The pill box on the cane is attachable. Convenience and peace of mind may result from this, particularly for people with particular medical requirements.
Portable and Compact: A foldable cane that is convenient to carry or store. For elderly people who might need to travel or store the cane in confined areas, this would be perfect.
Integrated Flashlight: The handle has a small LED light that can be activated by pressing a button, making it useful in dimly lit or dark areas.
Comfortable Grip: A handle with an ergonomic design that eases wrist and hand strain. Soft, textured material might be used to keep hands from slipping, even when they are sweating.
Today we had a client-designer zoom meeting. As designers, group 10 were concerned about reflecting the culture and joy of Spain in the product. As clients we demand for the product not to look like a souvenir, taht for we provide some inspirational photos. We also clarify that there is no budget, we expect four our designers to be competitive with existing solutions; if results in an expensive product we expect to be justified with added values.
As designers, group 8 we made clear our due dates. We explained that now we are in a concept ideation phase. Next week we will expose the main concepts to our clients and in the following week we will start converging the ideas into 1 product. The final proposal can be finished by the end of November.
